HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge (CF258A)
Value & Price Guide
Got a brand new HP 58A black toner cartridge here. It's still in the original box, never opened. These are great for the LaserJet Pro M404 and M428 series printers. I bought an extra one and ended up not needing it, so my loss is your gain. Perfect if you do a lot of printing and want the official HP quality without paying full retail price at the big box stores. Box has a little shelf wear but the toner inside is sealed and ready to go.
Current value
$42 - $65
Condition
New
Sales tracked
14 listings
Have this item? Sell it in seconds.
📸 Take a photo → 💰 Get an instant price → 🚀 List on eBay & Facebook Marketplace
Recent listings & comparables
Based on marketplace listings similar to this item
HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge CF258A
$125
New OEM HP 58A M404 M428 M430 Toner Cartridge CF258A
$74.99
HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge CF258A New Open Box
$70.99
HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge, ~3,000 pages, CF258A
$255.55
HP LaserJet 58A Black CF258A Toner Cartridge With Open Box Weight: 1lb:7.5oz
$53.99
What affects the value?
Key factors collectors and buyers usually evaluate
Condition and packaging
Mint in package examples usually command a premium over loose items with card wear, creases, or yellowing.
Edition rarity
Specific runs and harder-to-find variants generally sell higher than common releases from the same year.
Buyer demand
Recent buyer activity changes quickly. Comparable sold listings are a better signal than asking prices.
Completeness
Original packaging, inserts, and cleaner presentation can materially improve resale value.
Ready to sell your HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge (CF258A)?
Get an instant price, generate a polished listing, and publish to major marketplaces in seconds.
Frequently asked questions
Hero Stuff analyzes thousands of recent sales across multiple marketplaces to provide you with an accurate, real-time price range for your item. We take into account the condition, completeness, and current market trends.
The most significant factors are the condition of the item, whether you have the original box and accessories, and the current market demand. Items in "Like New" or "Mint" condition typically sell for more.
The best places to sell depend on your item. Generally, eBay, Facebook Marketplace, and Mercari are top choices for electronics and collectibles. Hero Stuff helps you list across these platforms efficiently.
Check recent sold listings rather than active asking prices. Hero Stuff does this automatically for you, filtering out outliers to give you a realistic expectation of what your item will sell for.
An item is considered "New" only if it is still factory sealed. Having the original packaging and accessories can increase resale value by 15-20% compared to the loose item alone, as it appeals to collectors and gift buyers.
This HP 58A Black Original LaserJet Toner Cartridge (CF258A) value and price guide is based on verified marketplace listing data and comparable item analysis. Prices shown are market-informed and can change over time.
Hero Stuff helps you sell used items fast with AI-assisted pricing, listing creation, and cross-posting to eBay and Facebook Marketplace.